Why the banks with most to gain from tokenisation move last

The banks with the most to gain from tokenised money are the ones taking longest to adopt it. London, New York and Tokyo move more money in and out than anywhere else, so on paper they benefit most from putting it on chain.

Yet most stablecoin volume today flows somewhere else entirely. I put that contradiction to Tim Way, Senior Director for Global Banking at Fireblocks, when we sat down in Singapore this week, and asked whether the hold-up is technology or people.

Friction decides who goes first

Tim Way, Senior Director for Global Banking at Fireblocks

Way’s answer starts with where the pain is. He sees three tiers, central bank money, wholesale markets and retail, each moving at its own speed. Most stablecoin volume today is going to or from the global south or some kind of retail use, he said, “simply because that’s where the most friction today is”.

Wholesale markets have plenty to gain, and he pointed out that the studies showing it have come from banks themselves, not from vendors. But he has also been the person responsible for upgrading a core banking system. “If upgrading a core banking system in one bank is an 18-month effort, then there’s a lot of process, not just technology, that is also required to support digital assets,” he said.

There is a commercial logic to the caution as well. These institutions have very large businesses that they do not want to put at risk. So they are starting in the places where the business case is material, “rather than rewiring the absolute hub of what they’re doing”.

Another ledger, not another bank

I asked whether banks are treating tokenised money as one more thing bolted on to an old core, or as a reason to modernise it. His answer was that it depends on the bank, and that Fireblocks works with both approaches.

Some of the work sits inside the core banking providers. Fireblocks recently announced its work with Fiserv in the United States, where its technology underpins the issuing and holding of stablecoins for Fiserv’s clients. Way expects that to become standard. “The ability to send, hold, receive stablecoins is going to be a necessity for core banking systems,” he said. In the longer run he goes further: “I firmly believe that actually the whole of the core banking stack is eventually going to be reframed.”

Other banks, especially large incumbents, have chosen to run several cores side by side, using providers such as Thought Machine and Episode Six, both Fireblocks partners, to add products quickly on a new subledger. That gave him the simplest description of the technology I have heard. “One way of thinking of digital assets and the blockchain is that it’s another subledger,” he said. “It’s just a subledger for digital assets rather than traditional assets.”

Can one platform handle stablecoins, tokenised deposits, bonds and funds? Technically, yes. Whatever a bank issues, it needs the same security layer and the same control layer: who signs off, what the instruction contains, and whether to release it on chain. The business reality is messier, because the part of a bank that issues debt has little in common with the part that runs receivables for corporates or the part that manages funds. What Way sees at the largest banks is a shared platform that each of those businesses can use. A fungible token built for a stablecoin can be reused for a unit of a fund. A bond that pays coupons on chain needs a different token standard, but it sits on the same foundation.

One set of controls

What banks want from all this is less exotic than the technology suggests. They are not especially worried about the smart contract, Way said. Their question is: “Can I apply the existing control framework that I’ve got across all of my asset classes?” A single control layer means one conversation with the chief information security officer, compliance and operational risk. Without it, “you’d have to have 15 different conversations”.

Regulatory clarity remains the gate. “They’ll do POCs and pilots to prove value, but moving something into production, you’re a bank. You’ve got to be regulatory compliant,” he said.

I suggested that this makes the choice of technology almost secondary. He disagreed. The value stolen in security incidents has risen this year, and “picking the right partner with the right security is paramount”. Banks have firm preferences on how the keys that release a transaction are protected, whether through multi-party computation or a hardware security module, and on whether they run the service in the cloud or in their own environment. Even banks under the same regulator end up with different requirements. “It’s how they choose to comply with the regulations,” he said.

Asia’s opening

The idea I most wanted to test was whether Asia could settle more of its trade in its own currencies using stablecoins. Coming from London, where the eurozone already has its payment networks, I had assumed the banks had long since solved the problem. In Asia they have not.

Way thinks the opportunity is real because tokenised payments change the risk. There is far less time between the intent to pay and the money arriving, so much of the risk that sat in that gap falls away. With every party on one common ledger, the cost of moving between currencies, and between stablecoins and conventional money, should compress. “That’s not what we see today, but that’s an opportunity,” he said.

Europe gains less because one leg of most European trade is already in the eurozone. In Asia both sides are often paying for a currency conversion and routing through New York. “These things are ultimately going to be driven by commercial consequences,” he said. If neither party needs a dollar transaction, that could widen the use of the yen, the Singapore dollar or the Hong Kong dollar to settle trade in the region.

He was careful about the conditions. Regulated institutions at both ends would have to accept the stablecoin, and market makers would need to run deep liquidity between pairs such as the yen and the rupiah, which do not exist today. “I can’t predict where that’s going to go,” he said. “There’s a genuine opportunity here.”

Will customers notice?

My last question was whether any of this reaches ordinary customers. Way’s evidence is in Fireblocks’ own numbers. Two years ago stablecoins were roughly half of the volume on its platform. Today they are 75 per cent. Digital assets, he said, have moved “from being a crypto speculation use case to being a transfer of value use case”.

The benefit is clearest where moving money is hardest, which is why adoption started in emerging markets. It will spread as scale brings costs down. About 1.6 per cent of the US dollar M1 money supply is on chain in stablecoins today, he said. If that reached five per cent, the cost of the infrastructure would be shared across far more participants and the cost of moving on and off chain would fall.

I offered my own comparison, the switch from analogue to digital television: less a revolution than a clunky system quietly replaced by a better one that saves everyone a few per cent. Way added the part I had missed. New rails let new firms into the value chain. Revolut, a Fireblocks customer, changed what people expect from a bank, and he sees no reason for firms like it to stay in retail. “They’re not going to stop at the consumer banking level,” he said.

That is the direction he sees for digital assets as a whole: out of consumer fintech and into wholesale banking.

The post Why the banks with most to gain from tokenisation move last appeared first on The Fintech Times.

Read More

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *